Men's All-American all-conference

Year	All-Region I (DII since 2021)
2023	Greyson Akers (2nd Team) All-American
2002	Yotuel Garcia (1st team), Regional champion, all-ACCAC (1st team), All-American, National Champion, National Athlete of the Year Javier Garcia (1st team), all-ACCAC (1st team), All-American Hayden Gelder (2nd team) all-ACCAC (2nd team), All-American Joshua Lumpkin (2nd team) all-ACCAC (2nd team) Yael Caballero Ferro (3nd team) Greyson Akers (3rd team) Wyatt Williams (3rd team)
2021	Yotuel Garcia (1st team), Regional champion, All-American Connor King (1st team), All-American Brandon Wilson (2nd team) Masen Hofmann (2nd team) Geoffrey Grossthal (3rd team)
2020	No team due to COVID-19
2019	Flynn Fuhrmann, All-American Andrew McCumber (1st team) Jalen Chee (Hon. Men.)
2018	Tristan Stellmach All-American Andrew McCumber
2017	Felix Rios Amir Husen
2016	Zach Harrach (1st team) Carlin Resendez (2nd team) Chris McCoy (Honrable Mention)
2013	Gerardo Villagome All-American Eduardo Ro All-American
2012	Eduardo Roa All-American
2011	Carlos Roa All-American
2010	Carlos Roa (2nd Team) All-American Abdikani Ismail (Honorable Mention) All-American Brian Sullivan (Honorable Mention)
2004	Calvin Fife All-American, National Champion
2003	Calvin Fife Nathan Ostler
2002	Nathan Ostler All-American, NJCAA DII 12th Place Bryan Yazzie All-American, NJCAA DII 9th Place
1998	Curtis Clark All-American
1997	Jason Cupryk All-American
1996	Jason Cupryk Mario Gomez
1995	Ron Clary Mario Gomez Steven Riggs
1994	Ron Clary Aaron Jones
1993	Leonard Montoya Darren Walker
1992	Lester Madison Leonard Montoya Steven Riggs Francis Walsh
1991	Daniel Lewis Lester Madison John McCleve Francis Walsh
1990	Robert Barrios
1989	Robert Barrios
1987	Byran Stone All-American Billy Skinner
1985	David Spargo
1984	Tim Wakefield
1983	Milfried Tewawina Jeff Reardon
1980	Don Janicki
1970	James Euell All-American
1968	Bob Boglione All-American
1967	Bob Boglione All-American