All-Americans, All-Conference
| All-ACCAC | Year | All-Region I |
|---|---|---|
| Orlando Gonzalez (2nd Team) | 2023-24 | |
| Lual Lual (2nd Team) | 2023-24 | Lual Lual (2nd Team) |
| Timmy Johnson (3rd team) | 2022-23 | Timmy Johnson (2nd team) |
| 2021-22 | B.J. Burries (2nd team) | |
| No season due to COVID-19 | 2020-21 | |
| Rajihan Billingsley (2nd team) | 2019-20 | Rajihan Billingsley (1st team) |
| Rajihan Billingsley (3rd team) | 2018-19 | Rajihan Billingsley (2nd team |
| Elijah Moore (3rd team) | 2018-19 | Elijah Moore (2nd team) |
| Adonis Arms (3rd team) | 2017-18 | Adonis Arms (3rd team) |
| Jamil Wilson-Jones (2nd team) | 2016-17 | Jamil Wilson-Jones (2nd team) |
| Obi Megwa (2nd team) | 2015-16 | Obi Megwa (2nd team) |
| Khari Holloway (1st team) 2nd Team All-American | 2014-15 | Khari Holloway (1st team) |
| Kyle Bingham (3rd team | 2014-15 | Kyle Bingham (2nd team) |
| Camyn Boone (1st team) | 2013-14 | |
| Shy McClelland (1st team) | 2013-14 | |
| Christian Griggs-Williams (2nd team) | 2012-13 | Christian Griggs-Williams (2nd team |
| Eric Hunt (2nd team) | 2012-13 | Eric Hunt (2nd team) |
| Tylor Wimbish (Honorable Mention) | 2012-13 | |
| Shyheim McClelland (Honorable Mention) | 2012-13 | |
| Asaad Woods (2nd team) | 2011-12 | Asaad Woods (2nd team) |
| Christian Griggs-Williams (3rd team) | 2011-12 | |
| John Balwigaire (2nd Team) | 2010-11 | John Balwigaire (1st Team) |
| Stephen Rogers (1st Team) Player of the Year, FOY, 2nd Team All-American | 2009-10 | Stephen Rogers (1st Team) |
| Eric Hunt (3rd Team) | 2009-10 | Eric Hunt (2nd Team) |
| Clint Hamilton (2nd Team) | 2008-09 | Clint Hamilton (2nd Team) |
| John Pena (1st Team) | 2007-08 | John Pena (1st Team) |
| David Jackson (3rd Team) | 2007-08 | |
| Jesse Childs (3rd Team) | 2007-08 | |
| Gabe Freeman (1st Team) | 2006-07 | Gabe Freeman (1st Team) |
| Adam McCoy (2nd Team) | 2006-07 | Adam McCoy (2nd Team) |
| Gabe Freeman (1st Team) | 2005-06 | Gabe Freeman (1st Team) |
| Art Donzella (Honorable Mention) | 2005-06 | |
| Quinn Barfield (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 2004-05 | Quinn Barfield (1st Team) |
| Nate Perry (2nd Team) | 2004-05 | Nate Perry (2nd Team) |
| Ryan Rourke (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 2003-04 | Ryan Rourke (1st Team) |
| Fred Marshall (2nd Team) | 2003-04 | Fred Marshall (1st Team) |
| Hakeem Rollins (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 2002-03 | Hakeem Rollins (1st Team) |
| Rayshawn Ames (2nd Team) | 2002-03 | Rayshawn Ames (2nd Team) |
| 2001-02 | Ryan Tricco (2nd Team) | |
| Jorge Rochin (1st Team) | 1999-00 | Jorge Rochin (1st Team) |
|
Ernest Brown (1st Team) Player of the Year, FOY, 1st Team All-American |
1998-99 | |
| Thomas Watkins (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American | 1998-99 | |
| Nick Greene (1st Team) | 1998-99 | |
| Karee Anderson (1st Team) | 1996-97 | Karee Anderson (1st Team) |
| Jason Richey (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American | 1995-96 | |
| Jamal Livingston (2nd Team) | 1995-96 | |
| Marc McDowell (Honorable Mention) | 1995-96 | |
| Ryan Abbot (Honorable Mention) | 1994-95 | |
| Jamal Livingston (Honorable Mention) | 1994-95 | |
| M'Kay McGrath 3rd Team All-American | 1989-90 | |
| Juan Thomas Honorable Mention All-American | 1988-89 | |
| Mark Manor 3rd Team All-American | 1984-85 | |
| Tim Vanda Honorable Mention All-American | 1981-82 | |
| Byron Walker Honorable Mention All-American | 1980-81 | |
| Ken Troutt | 1977-78 | |
| Huey Lowery | 1977-78 | |
| Charles Farrell | 1977-78 | |
| Ed Dawson | 1976-77 | |
| George Hall 2nd Team All-American | 1975-76 | |
| Ed Dawson | 1975-76 | |
| Kelly Cordes | 1974-75 | |
| George Hall | 1974-75 | |
| Jimmy Stewart | 1973-74 | |
| Willard Tsingine | 1973-74 | |
| David Royse | 1973-74 | |
| Scott Burdette | 1972-73 | |
| Andy Shumway | 1972-73 | |
| Aaron Hopwood | 1972-73 | |
| Jerry Lee | 1972-73 | |
| James McClelland | 1971-72 | |
| Ed Weatherspoon Honorable Mention All-American | 1970-71 | |
| Edd Gardner | 1970-71 | |
| Perry Bass | 1969-70 | |
| Ed Weatherspoon | 1969-70 | |
| Stan McClelland | 1968-69 | |
| Cephus Weatherspoon | 1968-69 | |
| Gary Ernst | 1967-68 | |
| Ted Nite | 1967-68 | |
| Charles McCormick | 1967-68 | |
| Mike Swinford | 1967-68 | |
| Craig Darrington | 1966-67 | |
| Rich Daniel | 1966-67 | |
| Tim Varela | 1966-67 | |
| Jim Christensen | 1966-67 | |
| K.C. Abney | 1965-66 | |
| Del Moody | 1965-66 | |
| Eric Shumway | 1965-66 |