| Olivia Rodina Region I DII (2nd Team) |
2023 |
| Rylee Rottweiler (1st team) |
2022 |
| Annabella Bara (1st team) Hon. Men. All-American |
2021 |
| Rylee Rottweiller (1st team) |
2021 |
| Randie Holmes (2nd team) |
2021 |
| *Season canceled due to COVID-19 |
2020 |
| Annabella Bara (1st team) |
2019 |
| Kyla Galdos (Hon. Men.) |
2019 |
| Lisbeth Medina (1st team) |
2018 |
| Caitlyn Waller (2nd team) |
2018 |
| Megan Belles (Hon. Men.) |
2018 |
| Emily Lynch (2nd team) |
2017 |
| Maddison Ross (2nd team) |
2017 |
| Sydney White (1st team) |
2016 |
| Mala Gajete (Hon. Men.) |
2016 |
| Riana Poarch (2nd team) |
2015 |
| Jessica Lynn (2nd team) |
2015 |
| Bailey Skipper (Hon. Men.) |
2015 |
| Danielle Torres (1st team) |
2014 |
| Morgan Eddy (2nd team) |
2014 |
| Hannah Kijowski (Hon. Men.) |
2014 |
| Jordan Drake (1st team) |
2013 |
| Morgan Eddy (1st team) |
2013 |
| Hallee Ahler (Honorable Mention) |
2013 |
| Kirsten Ryan (1st team) |
2012 |
| Allie Budge (2nd team) |
2012 |
| Elise Griego (Honorable Mention) |
2012 |
| Andrea Duke (1st team) |
2011 |
| Kirsten Ryan (Honorable Mention) |
2011 |
| Andrea Duke (2nd Team) |
2010 |
| Rihana Shah (2nd Team) |
2010 |
| Lindsey Cerqua (1st Team) |
2009 |
| Mary Koleski (1st Team) |
2008 |
| Kayla Szeliga (2nd Team) |
2008 |
| Katie Renteria (Honorable Mention) |
2008 |
| Dana Carver (1st Team) |
2007 |
| Krista Mirabella (2nd Team) |
2007 |
| Melissa Cascio (2nd Team) |
2007 |
| Krista Mirabella (1st Team) 2nd Team All-American |
2006 |
| Andrea Evans (1st Team) |
2006 |
| Celene Morlera (1st Team) |
2006 |
| Cammi Keller (Honorable Mention) |
2006 |
| Rocky Bush (Honorable Mention) |
2006 |
| Amanda Nance (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American |
2005 |
| Ashley Straub (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American |
2005 |
| Brittany Wilds (1st Team) |
2005 |
| Ashley Hale (2nd Team) |
2005 |
| Michelle Martinez (2nd Team) |
2005 |
| Ree-Ann Fozy (Honorable Mention) |
2005 |
| Chelsea Johnson (1st Team) |
2004 |
| Michelle Martinez (1st Team) |
2004 |
| Amanda Nance (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American, NJCAA All-Tournament Team |
2004 |
| Ashley Straub (2nd Team) |
2004 |
| Heather Perry (2nd Team) |
2004 |
| Nicole Prather (2nd Team) |
2004 |
| Kim Kukla (2nd Team) |
2004 |
| Kristina Burris (1st Team) 2nd Team All-American |
2003 |
| Alli Landon (1st Team) 3rd Team All-American |
2003 |
| Stephanie Prouty (1st Team) |
2003 |
| Elise Pellant (Honorable Mention) |
2003 |
| Lauren Thomas (Honorable Mention) |
2003 |
| Kristina Burris (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American |
2002 |
| Kynan Sullivan (1st Team) |
2002 |
| Alli Landon (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American |
2002 |
| Stacy Anderson (2nd Team) |
2002 |
| Elise Pellant (Honorable Mention) |
2002 |
| Laurel Schmadel (Honorable Mention) |
2002 |
| Melissa Miller (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American |
2001 |
| Colleen Fellin (1st Team) 2nd Team All-American |
2001 |
| Kristen Purpura (1st Team) |
2001 |
| Krista Case (1st Team) |
2001 |
| Kynan Sullivan (1st Team) |
2001 |
| Krista Hecker (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American |
2000 |
| Kristen Purpura (1st Team) |
2000 |
| Colleen Fellin (2nd Team) |
2000 |
| Deb Daley (2nd Team) |
2000 |
| Kori Moore (2nd Team) |
2000 |
| Shannon Tenney (1st Team) Player of the Year, 1st Team All-American |
1999 |
| Alicia Milan (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American |
1999 |
| Jamie Klemmer (1st Team) |
1999 |
| Jennifer DeLaVega (2nd Team) |
1999 |
| Shannon Tenney (1st Team) |
1998 |
| Cara Destefano (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Alicia Milan (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Callie Cheek (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Natalie Boyd (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Jackie Evans (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Sarah Decker (2nd Team) |
1998 |
| Karie Richards (1st Team) Honorable Mention All-American |
1997 |
| Jesse Boyd (1st Team) |
1997 |
| Sarah Moravitz (1st Team) |
1997 |
| Angie Jibben (1st Team) |
1997 |
| Ammie Leeker (2nd Team) |
1997 |
| Sarah Decker (2nd Team) |
1997 |
| Lisa Moon (2nd Team) |
1997 |
| Jesse Boyd (1st Team) |
1996 |
| Lisa Moon (1st Team) |
1996 |
| Sarah Moravitz (1st Team) |
1996 |
| Angie Jibben (1st Team) |
1996 |
| Micky Mendoza (2nd Team) |
1996 |
| Joanna Palmatier (2nd Team) |
1996 |
| Bethany Torres (2nd Team) |
1996 |
| Karen McCormick |
1996 |